The other two contestants earned places in the site as well (MarzGurl and ThatChickwiththeGoggles), but all of them started to gain major roles. Nostalgia Chick, unlike Nostalgia Critic who exists separately from Doug Walker, also acts as a fictionalized version of Ellis as her friends will often refer to her as Lindsay at many times.Įllis was elected in 2008 to be the Nostalgia Chick after winning with her review of Disney's Pocahontas. She is also a mastermind (although not the true antagonist) in the site's two year special " Kickassia". She is a female counterpart to the Nostalgia Critic elected in 2008. The Nostalgia Chick is a character in played by Lindsay Ellis. ~ The Nostalgia Chick trying to poison the Nostalgia Critic.